Sociology of Work Log in
  • Ê
  • Â
 Å

% Albert Felipe completed

In the second chapter of Weber’s book “The Spirit of Capitalism”, he uses Benjamin Franklin’s quote to set the tone of his argument and define capitalism. In the quote, capitalism is basically explained in various contexts; time is money, credit is money, money can beget money, money is earned, spent and can grow. Interestingly enough, Weber states that Franklin believed these ideals represent the spirit of capitalism and tied into the virtues of man. He goes to explain that these virtues of man such as honesty, punctuality, moral responsibility, can earn money and credit. Through his virtue and attitude, man can gain capital and increase his way into the world. Weber basically states that Franklin believed that man’s attitude and virtue was the base of capitalism and his ability to earn money.

The idea of greed and want for material things is also one of man’s virtues, according to Weber. In the true spirit of capitalism, Weber explains that man is dominated by the idea of making money and is not satisfied with the simplicity of Franklin’s version of capitalism. He goes on to mention that man’s need for economic acquisition becomes one of the major purposes of his life; not just mere virtue. In other words, man’s earning power and gain of material possessions is tied into their professional activity by any means. The way I am to understand capitalism through this reading is the way it exists today. Survival of the fittest through the power of earning capability; not through virtue or religion as in our previous readings.

When I think of this reading, it reminds me of the discussion in our last class. The question that was proposed for discussion was “If you had to choose between Happiness or Wealth, which would you choose?” In the context of this article, it seems as if the clear answer to the question would be wealth. It seems that the ultimate prize to the spirit of capitalism is individual monetary wealth. It can be argued that the access to anything in life (even virtue) would happen through the access of wealth. Is this what Weber meant when he included the idea of rationalism? In my perspective, I believe he did. I basically believe Weber stated that the world has convinced itself that wealth is the means to access the best quality life. Well, in my humble opinion, I guess this is why we may be so unhappy.

 Å

% Ebony Parchment completed

In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism by Max Weber Weber coated lines written by Benjamin Franklin to describe the spirit of capitalism  where he stated :

“Remember, that time is money. He that can earn ten shillings

a day by his labour, and goes abroad, or sits idle, one-half of

that day, though he spends but sixpence during his diversion or

idleness, ought not to reckon that the only expense; he has

really spent, or rather thrown away, five shillings besides” (weber14).

Franklin was saying that our time equaled money and a person can either work for their money or go idle and spend the little that they have. But money can disappear as easy as it’s received. Plus, from I am drawing I think he believes that a man who works hard for their money would consider the and be more mindful of how he spends that money compared to one that did not work for it.

He connected rationalism and the spirit of capitalism by looking at capitalism as the pursuit of renewable profit. Everything is done in terms of balances, the amount of money gained versus how much is spent. He also quoted franklin on how money equals credit and how the government gets the interest.  “Remember, that credit is money. If a man lets his money lie in my hands after it is due, he gives me the interest, or so much as I can make of it during that time. This amounts to a considerable sum where a man has good and large credit and makes good use of it”. Here he talks about business and loans and if you borrow and don’t pay on time they make a profit. This is where they rob poor people  who worked hard for their money. It’s all a money making business where the poor suffers.

Weber believes that Franklin’s idea is not about making an honest living and finding their way in the world and the work ethic is more of a forgetful duty. And it’s more about profit and greed.  He believed  Benjamin Franklin was irrational and that making money was just a means of supplying material needs. And the drive to earn more and more money is a means to and end because you spend all your time at work and not enjoying life.  He thought that capitalism was more than money and wealth to gain economic status.

 Å

% Crystal Pinho completed

Weber views this increasing philosophy of materialism as an end in itself. Modern capitalism exudes this sense of duty to prosper. In order for Weber to best illustrate his method, he utilizes Benjamin Franklin theories and famous quote “time is money…” Franklin exemplifies the spirit of capitalism. His quote expresses different forms of money—Time is money, Credit is money, and money has the ability to produce more money. Consistently paying your bills on time will encourage a form of confidence and trust. Franklin’s ethical principles relate to the usefulness in the hopes of promoting profits.

The rational ethics of capitalism does not grasp this self-indulgent lifestyle; Franklin embodies. During the middle Ages, Franklin’s methods would have been seen as, nothing more than greed. This attitude towards money is the primary reason for capitalism. It expresses a similar feeling associated with religion.  The desirable quality of earning money mirrors the competence of a higher calling.  In my opinion, capitalism acts as another form of Darwinism.

Weber was significantly influenced by Franklin’s concept of capitalism and its effects on society. The money earned should be reinvested into capital.  His views of money were more rational. Benjamin Franklin followed the path of science, which all knowledge inspires from experiences.

 Å

% Marien Burgos completed

Marien Burgos

He that is Known to pay punctually and exactly to the time he promises, may at any time, and on any occasion, raise all the money his friends can spare” by this passage Weber means That the person who builds a good reputation towards money opens doors that may otherwise be close. If the lender can see you are trying and making an effort to pay him his money he will probably feel stimulate to give you a chance to pay his money back, but if he doesn’t see you making an effort to return the money, he will probably think again to lend you money one more time.

The connection between them is that Weber was influenced by Benjamin he understood how capitalism worked before it started being in implemented in America. Weber quoted Benjamin Franklin an consider his believes as rules to live by if you were interested in being successful in life and business. Also he thought that if you lived your life and were greed towards you would see an increasing capital in the end. Weber thought that it was a rule to live by and the person would be seen as a prosperous person.

This life style of earning money is seen as an point in itself, and is only the instrument for buying more things. Even though this attitude towards money is apparently illogical this is the principle of capitalism ,And this is closely related with some religious ideas.

Weber thought that capitalism was more than accumulation of money and wealth. He believed capitalism was thinking more rationally than just making and accumulating wealth using discipline when working hard. Weber consider that in order for people to become strong capitalist, it had to start as a way of life. He consider you had to invest your capital regularly. Weber did not think this develop as a reflection of other economic situations because other places in the country had the “spirit of capitalism” before it stated to take shape all over the country.

In conclusion Weber took Benjamin Franklin’s idea as the core of what capitalism is and how it had to be enforced in order for us to live in a capitalist society. The only difference was that Weber was more rational than Franklin. He thought we had to be rational about money and what we should invest and make money grow. A person who makes a good reputation towards money will be prosperous because this attitude will open doors for the person in the future. But Benjamin Franklin believed in the theory that all knowledge is derived from sense experience. Stimulated by the rise of experimental science.

 Å

% Elizabeth Bullock completed

Due Sunday, September 11th, by midnight. Word count: 400 words. Please make sure everything is in your own words. Do not include any quotes and if you paraphrase make sure to include the proper citation.

In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber (:14-15) draws on the writing of Benjamin Franklin to describe the spirit of capitalism. Making reference to the passage from Franklin that Weber quotes at length, explain the connection Weber is underlining here, between rationalism and the spirit of capitalism.

 Å

% Toniann German completed

Toniann German

Assignment #1

Sociology of work

Introduction to work ethic

My Name is Toniann German, I signed up for this course because I enjoyed taking the sociology of family last semester and was interested in learning about the sociology of work. I also signed up for this class because I enjoy taking hybrid courses.  I currently work as a preschool teacher in the south Bronx. I previously was an environmental high school teacher however I decided to switch paths due to the fact that I was obtaining my degree in Early Childhood Education. I always wanted to be a teacher from a very young age, I feel that the only way to see change in the world is to start to enforce change in the younger generations. My mother always enforced the importance of education and going to college. My mother was very adamant about her daughters working at a very young age and understanding what it means to make your own money, not having to depend on anyone. My grandparents taught me the importance in other things such as caring for your home and appreciating nature. My grandmother was never much of a worker, her work was in her garden among the hundreds of flowers and plants that she adores more than anything. My grandfather on the other hand has always been a working man, never able to sit still and always up on a ladder fixing something. Reading Crawford’s reading this week I can honestly say that my grandparents taught me the importance of building and fixing things on your own. Technology was never allowed during summer vacations, gardening and house work was not an option. I feel that my education has prepared me to be a knowledge worker however my parents and grandparents have taught me the importance of physical labor.

What I got from Weber’s reading is that sometimes your affiliations and where you rank in life can affect the work choices you make.   I also feel that Weber is trying to say that when one works with purpose it increases economic growth. I feel personally that my work ethic is based on morals and happiness not so much financial gain. My grandparents would say “The best kind of work, is the kind that you find fun.”

 Å

% Maggie Wiesner completed

 

I am currently working as a Senior Case Manager for a non-profit organization called Safe Horizon, which serves crime victims across New York City. My office specifically works with survivors of domestic violence and I really love working there and what I do.

As I shared in class, my grandparents and parents all worked at ‘blue collar’ jobs, as have many other family members.  The fact that all of my grandparents and parents did not go to college, really pushed them to encourage me to do so.  They felt that a higher education could lead to a better paying job and I would not have to struggle financially as they did sometimes.  They also had good work ethics and were very responsible.  They did not complain about their jobs or having to go to work.  I believe that all of this was passed down to me and how I approach the idea of working and my goals for the future.

In Part 2 of the Introduction of The Protestant Ethic and The Spirit of Capitalism, Max Weber states that modern capitalism has risen out of people being so consumed with making money just for the sake of making it and not to buy things they need to live (Weber, p.xi).  In the sense of people who work in fields that are known to pay well just for the sake of making a lot of money, I certainly do not share that work ethic.  The field I am in, social services, does not often pay very well and is not easy to do unless you really love it and want to help people.

Weber goes on to analyze the origins of capitalism and asses how capitalism related to Protestantism and Catholicism in “Religious Affiliation and Social Stratification”. Weber argued that the religions people followed were based on an individual’s economic status and that wealthier people were more inclined to follow Protestantism and to be supporters of capitalist ideals (Weber, p.4).  Weber further posits that the types of education people chose were those favored by their families and their communities and it was typical for Catholics to learn manual labor and to not prepare to be businessmen, unlike their Protestant counterparts, resulting in Catholics working in lower-paying industries and being less inclined to support capitalism (Weber, p.6).  I do agree with Weber that most people fall into practicing the religion they are born into, which is also usually what is popular in the communities in which they live.  If one’s religion dictates the type of education and job one will have, it can then be said that religion determines economic standing and therefore one’s views on capitalism and even their work ethic.  I agree with this to an extent.  I feel that many people who come from wealthier upbringings who do not  have to work as hard, if at all, to earn money, may have a less stronger work ethic than people who do not come from money and who have to work hard to earn the money that they do get, may have stronger work ethics.  Of course, this is not the case for everyone.

I do see this in my personal experience and work ethic.  I do not come from a wealthy family and have had to work since I was 15.  I was taught to work hard and do well to help ensure my employment and reputation and the money that I earn is needed.  I have also been taught that when one does earn beyond their means, giving it to less fortunate people is the right thing to do.

 Å

% Maggie Wiesner completed

Hello everyone,

 

My name is Maggie and this is my second semester at CWE. I have so far taken all of my other classes at the uptown campus but have had to start taking classes downtown due to my work schedule changing.  I really enjoyed being downtown last semester-the classes are smaller and the students are closer to my age and seem a little more serious and excited about their education.  I wish I had known this earlier so I could have taken all of my classes at CWE!  But I am graduating in the winter so this will be my last semester…yay!

 

I had two reasons for being interested in this class. I took Professor Bullock’s class last semester and I really liked how it was set up.  Like this semester, we were assigned readings from different books and articles.  I feel that allows students to not just read one textbook by one author, but gives different points of views and insights of different authors, and allows us to read things we may normally not.  I also just thought that learning about the forces behind why people may choose the work that they do would be really interesting, especially in a place and time where there are certain professions that are known ‘money-makers’ but that may not necessarily require as much skill and effort as those which are not as lucrative.

 

I am majoring in sociology and minoring in psychology. I am very interested in the way people think and behave and feel that learning about people on an individual level as well as looking at them in groups on a more macro level gives the best picture of why we do what we do.  To continue my education, I would like to go to Hunter’s School of Social Work.  I finally reached my goal of working with the population I wanted to-survivors of domestic violence.  I would like to further my knowledge in counseling people by studying social work.

 

It was nice meeting you all last Wednesday and I am looking forward to everyone’s presentations and more class discussions!

 

Maggie Wiesner

 

 Å

% Denise Hines completed

Denisse Hines
Sociology of Work
Dr. Elizabeth Bullock
4 September 2016

What is Work?

I am working as an Assistant to the Associate Provost for Research at the City College main campus. I have been working at this job for a little over two years. Before this job, I worked for various companies doing office management.

All four of my grandparents lived in Dominican Republic. On my maternal side, my grandfather worked as a heavy equipment operator. He specifically he operated the asphalt roller during the times when highways and roads were being paved all over the country. He along with my grandmother who was a stay at home mom, would travel to different cities for months at a time while he worked at specific locations.

On my paternal side, my grandmother worked as an embroiderer for a men’s suit store. She embroidered men’s shirts, scarves, and jackets, Pocket Square etc. She did this most of her short adult life. My grandfather used to work as the social security ambulance driver. Both paternal grandparents passed away in their late 30’s from cancer.

My parents both work in education. My father started of his career as engineering in Dominican Republic. Our whole family migrated to the United States and he began to work as a mechanic to make ends meet. Later he finished his masters in Science and Mathematics and started working for the Board of Education as a Junior High School teacher. My mother was a stay at home mom for most of my childhood. As my siblings and I got older, she finished her degree and began working for the Board of Education as well. She works as a family worker in a Junior High School. They both found jobs with a steady paycheck and a bit more job security.

I think the work history of my parents specifically has instilled good work ethic in me. Unfortunately, this has also made me fearful of making career decisions that would make me happy rather than to seek financial independence perhaps as a business owner. This has affected me by making me a disciplined employee. I believe working and being compliant had been instilled into my parents from my grandparent in order to fulfill materialistic needs. I do think it is important to have steady income, but I do not agree with being tied down to whatever pays the bills if you do not feel any joy while working. My goals for my future is to find work that make me feel pleasant at the end of the workday that also fulfills my financial needs. I also hope to pass on good work ethic to my daughter without enforcing a strict view about working somewhere that may not make her happy.

Based on my understanding of Weber’s take on the ethic of work, I do think that we there are to very clear paths to work ethic in people. Based on some religions, people are disciplined workers with a typical capitalistic mentality where material things and power motivate their work ethic. Other religions have beliefs of a higher calling and that would be what motivates their work ethic.

 Å

% Janeth Solis completed

Hi Class,

My name is Janeth and I migrated to this country at the age of 9 with my parents and younger brother from Colombia. As an immigrant who has always been surrounded by a very hard working family, I hold a great deal of respect and admiration for all those who have paved the way for us all. I received my first job at the age of 16, as one of m High School’s teacher recommended me to a colleague who was looking for students to work at her costume jewelry shop on the weekends. I recalled taking the Long Island Railroad with three other classmates to Amityville, long Island on Saturdays, for an entire school year. I enjoyed that experience very much. I feel for the most part, that I have been very fortunate in most of my jobs that I have held. I believe that this Sociology of Work class will give us a better understanding of what is currently happening in the work force. I Especially believe it will help us decipher what our current politicians are trying to persuade us to believe about the current work markets.

I was recently promoted to administrative manager of personnel and academic affairs to the division of Cardiology at Columbia Medical Center. I have been working for Columbia University for about 10 years and have been very fortunate to have wonderful working environments. As for the work history of my grandparents, both sets of grandparents worked in Farms. My fathers’ parents own their own land and my mother’s parents were field workers. Both sets of grand parents were both very hard working as they often told stories of how early they were up working. As for my parents my mom was a stay at home mom and my dad worked as a mechanic. When we moved to the states they both when to work in factories, my mom as a seamstress and my dad as a technician who repaired the sewing machines.

I believe that my grandparents and parents have always stressed the importance of giving your all in whatever we were doing. My parents didn’t get a chance to go on to college because they were busy making a living and supporting their family, but they have always stressed the importance of finishing what we have started, therefor I have always wanted to finish my degree as I had to stop going to school to raise my kids. I give my parents thanks for being my role models and for teaching the importance of working hard.

In reading Max Weber’s excerpt, the statement that stuck out to me was when he quotes a writer trying to show the difference of the attitudes between the protestant and the Catholic religions, towards the economic life:

” The Catholic is quieter, having less of the acquisitive impulse; he prefers a life of the greatest possible security, even with a smaller income, to a life of risk and excitement, even though it may bring the chance of gaining honor and riches. The proverb says jokingly, “Either eat well or sleep well”. In the present case the Protestant prefers to eat well, the Catholic to sleep undisturbed” (p 8).

This statement very clearly states how the Protestantism believes largely influenced people to work hard to be able to accumulate wealth and live well. As per Catholicism influence people to take care of themselves and live peaceful lives, without stressing and killing themselves working. My parents raised us with Catholics believes that have influenced my work ethics. I do work hard because it’s the right thing to do not because I will get rich. My parents worked hard to make sure we had a roof over our heads but they stressed the value of our family and providing a good foundation for their children.